Schumpeter | The financial crisis

Unhappy birthday

It began five years ago

By A.P.

THERE is a debate to be had over when precisely the financial crisis began. But five years ago today, on August 9th 2007, is the strongest candidate. That was when BNP Paribas stopped withdrawals from three investment funds because it could not value their holdings, and in particular their subprime-mortgage assets. “The complete evaporation of liquidity in certain market segments of the US securitisation market has made it impossible to value certain assets fairly regardless of their quality or credit rating,” was the way the French bank put it in a statement issued that day.

BNP was not the first to reach that conclusion. Bear Stearns, one of many names not to have survived the intervening five years, had stopped fund redemptions in July, for example. The increasing difficulties of America’s housing market had been evident for months. But the BNP news prompted the first big policy response from central banks to evaporating liquidity in interbank markets, as the European Central Bank immediately conducted a special refinancing operation. The credit crunch was officially on, and so was a crisis that has since brought down banks, throttled economic growth, changed the way finance is regulated, raised deep questions about the efficacy of markets and threatened the existence of the euro. Anniversaries are seldom epochal, but this one is.

And even though this is a birthday with nothing to celebrate, it is an excuse to repeat my favourite quote of the crisis. It is recounted by Alistair Darling, a former British chancellor, and inevitably comes from the lips of George Bush, reassuring the world’s finance ministers in November 2008 that Hank Paulson was on top of things. “You folks don’t need to worry. Hank’s got a handle on this. He’s going to freeze that liquidity.”

Discover more

And it's goodbye from us

The Schumpeter blog is closing down as we engage in some creative destruction at Economist.com

The world's biggest shakedown?

A labyrinthine legal landscape is making it harder than ever for corporate America to stay on the right side of the law, say our correspondents


The politics of price

This week: Surprisingly low oil prices, more bank fines and Chinese antitrust enforcement